Court Packing Issues Force Conservatives Off Biden Committee

Written By BlabberBuzz | Saturday, 16 October 2021 04:45 PM
3
Views 3.1K

Two conservatives backed out of engaging in President Joe Biden's bipartisan commission analyzing possible changes to the U.S. Supreme Court, as other legal experts in the group blamed a preliminary court reform draft for being partisan against court-packing.

The White House issued its preliminary draft discussion materials Thursday evening, before deliberations by the commission throughout a virtual hearing on Friday.

Before the hearing, conservatives Caleb Nelson, a law professor at the University of Virginia, and Jack Goldsmith, a law professor at Harvard, left the panel, according to the White House.

"These two commissioners have chosen to bring their involvement to a close," White House spokesman Andrew Bates announced in an emailed statement to Bloomberg. "We respect their decision and very much appreciate the significant contributions that they made during the last 5 months in terms of preparing for these deliberations."

Nelson emailed a statement to the outlet, explaining he "resigned from the Commission" and "was honored to be part of it" but did not include a further comment. Both Nelson and Goldsmith did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

 WATCH: ESPN HOST- DEMOCRAT STRATEGY IS NOT WORKINGbell_image

Many members of the bipartisan panel, now down two members from its original 36-person placement in April, called out the framing of discussion materials and claimed it lacked focus on institutional confidence, catering more toward partisan beliefs. Others explained that the materials are "biased" against court-packing.

The draft materials on Thursday included text favoring term limits for judges. The report further said Congress's legal ability to expand the size of the Supreme Court bench but cautioned against adding justices, an approach popular among some progressives in the Democratic Party.

"This entire discussion is framed in the context of partisan politics. And I actually think that is a disservice to the exploration of this issue," announced NAACP Legal Defense Fund President Sherrilyn Ifill regarding court-packing.

Ifill continued that some of those who favor court-packing have "genuine concerns" regarding the rule of law, among other matters.

The NAACP LDF president received support from former D.C. Circuit Judge Thomas Griffith, an former President George W. Bush appointee and firm detractor of court-packing.

 WATCH: 2004 SNL SKETCH: "DONALD TRUMP’S HOUSE OF WINGS”bell_image

 WELP, CLIMATE WARRIORS HAVE THEIR NEXT TARGET PICKED OUT...bell_image

 TAXPAYER DOLLARS AT WORK: OUTRAGE OVER UC BERKELEY'S TAYLOR SWIFT MARKETING CLASSbell_image

 HEARTBREAK AND BLAME: CITY OF BALTIMORE DECIDES WHO'S ACCOUNTABLE FOR FRANCIS SCOTT KEY BRIDGE COLLAPSEbell_image

 TRUMP POINTS (MIDDLE) FINGER AT BIDEN AS PRO-HAMAS DEMONSTRATIONS DESTROY THE IVY'Sbell_image

 DENVER MIGRANT ADVOCATES UNGRATEFULLY DECLARE WE SUCK AT TAKING CARE OF ILLEGALS...bell_image

 WATCH: SENATOR FETTERMAN SLAMS DEMOCRATS OVER 'CRAZY' RESPONSE TO IRAN'S ATTACKS ON ISRAELbell_image

 BREAKING: HAMAS RELEASES PROPAGANDA VIDEO FEATURING ISRAELI-AMERICAN HOSTAGE ALIVE...(WATCH HERE)bell_image

 TENSIONS BOIL OVER AS PRO-PALESTINE PROTESTERS ARE ARRESTED OUTSIDE TOP DEM LEADER'S HOMEbell_image

 RESEARCHERS BAFFLED: CUTTING-EDGE AI ALGORITHMS UNVEIL STARTLING POLITICAL INSIGHTSbell_image

 TECHNOLOGY FOR THE WIN: COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY MAKES MAJOR ANNOUNCEMENT IN THE WAKE OF ANTI-ISRAEL PROTESTSbell_image

 FIRST FLIGHT OUT: BIDEN'S NEW HAITI POLICY DRAWS WIDE CRITICISMbell_image

 BIDEN TAKES A JAB AT LAUREN BOEBERT WITH JUST TWO SIMPLE WORDS...bell_image

 WATCH: ALEC BALDWIN'S COFFEE SHOP CLASH GOES VIRAL: THIS WOMAN IS RELENTLESS!bell_image

 DEMOCRATIC SENATOR'S 'LATE-NIGHT ADVENTURE' LANDS HER IN VERY STICKY SITUATIONbell_image

 THE FAUCI FALLOUT: RFK JR. BLOWS LID OFF PANDEMIC POWER PLAYS (WATCH)bell_image

 VERDICT DRAMA GRIPS ARIZONA: RANCHER'S MURDER TRIAL TAKES UNEXPECTED TURNbell_image

 MONEY TALKS AND BULLSH*T WALKS: COLUMBIA RESPONDS TO ROBERT KRAFT PULLING SUPPORTbell_image

 GOP FIREBRAND DROPS BOMBSHELL "THEORY" ON HOW TRUMP'S CASE WILL PLAY OUTbell_image

 ILHAN OMAR’S DAUGHTER KICKED OUT OF COLUMBIA DORM: MEGYN KELLY’S RESPONSE IS BRUTALLY HONEST (AND HILARIOUS!)bell_image

"Although my guess [is] that Commissioner Ifill and I probably disagree on the merits of court expansion, I couldn't agree more with her comment about the way the issue is framed," Griffith announced.

While White House officials have said the draft materials only serve as an "assessment," some have stated that the commissioner's initial reaction to the framing of court-packing would lead to a softer tone when the final report is submitted to President Joe Biden in mid-November.

X