The 23-year-old star was mocked on social media soon after singing the Star Spangled Banner at the MLB's Home Run Derby event at Dodgers Stadium in Los Angeles on Monday.
Fans slammed him for turning in an off-pitch, off-key effort that had many tempted to press the mute button on their remote controls.
Gray's cover was quickly tied to other car crash versions of the anthem, including Fergie of Black Eyed Peas fame's awful performance at the 2018 NBA All Star Game, which was so lousy basketball superstar Steph Curry burst out laughing.
FROM CONTROVERSY TO COMPASSION: DANIEL SNYDER'S JAW-DROPPING GIFT LEAVES NATION IN AWE
He even compared actress Roseanne Barr's deliberately horrid singing at a San Diego Padres baseball game in 1990, which saw her booed so badly she blocked her ears before spitting on the pitcher's mound.
Gray might have more than 21 million monthly listeners on Spotify, but baseball fans didn't let that hold them back as they slammed him with insult after insult.
WATCH: RFK JR. WILL REVERSE 80 YEARS OF FARM POLICY
"I don't know who TF Conan Gray is but that was top 5 worst national anthem renditions I've ever heard," wrote Patrick Sheldon.
Zachary Krueger called for "a Congressional Committee that looks into who chose the singer for the National Anthem at the Home Run Derby' while commentator Darren Rovell tweeted, "There are so many great singers in this country, it's nearly impossible to have that bad of a national anthem."
JAMES CARVILLE'S CONTROVERSIAL CRITIQUE: IS WOKE CULTURE KILLING DEMOCRATIC SUPPORT?
"1.) Who is Conan Gray? 2.) He may very well be the worst national anthem singer of all time. Good lord," added Matt Williams.
"Bro, I think Conan Gray is tone deaf. That national anthem was as bad as Fergie's," tweeted Jake Riegel.
FROM CONTROVERSY TO COMPASSION: DANIEL SNYDER'S JAW-DROPPING GIFT LEAVES NATION IN AWE
Nevertheless, Gray's fans came to his defense on social media, stressing the tune "wasn't even his style of singing," claiming the performance was a "set-up" meant to make him look bad, and repeating their opinion that he "in fact CAN sing."
INTRUDER SLIPS PAST TSA, BOARDS DELTA PLANE, IN EPIC SECURITY FAILURE
WATCH: ATF IS SET TO CRIMINALIZE 10 MILLION AMERICANS
OHIO MAN SENTENCED TO PRISON FOR THREATENING ARIZONA GOVERNOR KATIE HOBBS, DETAILS RELEASED
TECH DIVORCE DRAMA TAKES A POLITICAL TWIST: RFK JR. TEAMS UP WITH SILICON VALLEY'S EX
CAUGHT ON CAMERA: BRAZEN BURGLARS IN LA USE SLEDGEHAMMERS TO TUNNEL THEIR WAY TO BUSINESSES
RUDY GIULIANI OVERHEARD SPILLING FINANCIAL WOES AND DETAILS ABOUT HIS "NIGHTMARE LIFE"
THE PLOT THICKENS: TRUMP CHEERS ON RFK JR'S RUN, BUT WHY?
LEAVE IT TO TRUMP: THE DAY WAS SUPPOSED TO BRING FINANCIAL DOOM, YET DON'S NET WORTH SURGES
MARK LEVIN REVEALS THE DARK ORIGINS FUELING GOVERNMENT CORRUPTION
FATHER SERVING FIVE LIFE SENTENCES FOR CHILDREN'S DEATHS MAKES SHOCKING PLEA TO GOVERNOR
TRUMP BLASTS RONNA MCDANIEL AFTER IMMEDIATE FIRING FROM NBC, AND HE DOES NOT HOLD BACK
BIDEN'S GOT SKELETONS IN HIS CLOSET: DID UNIVERSITY OF DELAWARE MISLEAD THE COURTS?
TENNESSEE MOM’S CLUMSY REACH ENDS IN DAUGHTER’S DEATH, NOW SHE’S BEGGING FOR FUNERAL FUNDS
FORMER HOUSE SPEAKER NEWT GINGRICH BLAMES THIS GUY FOR GOP CHAOS...
RUMORS SWIRL AROUND BALTIMORE BRIDGE CRASH AS DETAILS EMERGE
CHICK-FIL-A MAKES SHOCKING POLICY FLIP, LEAVING FANS VERY WEARY
Once the spectators had made it through the anthem, they saw Washington Nationals star Juan Soto take out the derby for the first time, beating Seattle Mariners rookie Julio Rodriguez to become the second-youngest winner of the event.